During the term
If you paid for a year, that rent stands for the year. A demand for more money mid-term, backed by a threat, is a demand you can refuse in writing.
At renewal
- Ask for the increase in writing, with reasons and enough notice to plan.
- Compare asking rents for similar properties on the same street before you respond.
- Offer alternatives: a smaller increase for a longer term, or an increase after listed repairs.
- Get any agreement recorded as a renewal, not a verbal understanding.
If it is unreasonable
A tenant can ask the court to determine a reasonable rent, and courts consider comparable properties and the condition of the premises. A dated condition record strengthens your position — a property with unresolved damp, leaks or wiring faults is not worth a premium rent.
General information for house hunters, not legal advice. Tenancy law differs by state and reforms are debated regularly — confirm the current position in your state, and take advice from a lawyer before acting on a dispute.